Tamiflu Side Effects for Children and Adults. Is it Dangerous?
Call 410-825-5287 for a free medical malpractice consultation
Nobody noticed Tamiflu side effects at first. When Tamiflu was first marketed to the public, only a small portion of the manufacturer's clinical trial data had ever been published. Once post-marketing data began to accumulate, a number of disconcerting adverse events began to attract the attention of independent scientists who requested that complete reports from all Tamiflu clinical trials be disclosed by the drug's manufacturer, Roche. Although Roche took several years to comply with the request, a reasonably complete analysis of Tamiflu's side effects, benefits and risks was finally established. It was concluded that the drug's active ingredient, oseltamivir, does slightly reduce the duration of flu-like symptoms, yet its mechanism of action is unclear and the drug significantly increases the risk of nausea, vomiting, headaches and dangerous psychiatric events, especially in children. No evidence exists in support of Tamiflu's ability to interrupt viral transmission from person to person, and symptom relief may simply be a side effect of the sedative properties associated with the drug. Numerous biases were noted in the trials, which were predominantly funded by the manufacturer. Tamiflu's benefits seem to have been dramatically overemphasized while Tamiflu side effects were conveniently swept under the rug.
Tamiflu Side Effects A Misleading Marketing Campaign
Since 1999, Roche has been manufacturing and selling its highly profitable oseltamivir drug branded under the name of Tamiflu. In spite of the fact that data from only two of the 40 Roche sponsored clinical studies had been published when Tamiflu hit the market, Tamiflu's marketing campaign was so successful that governments throughout the world spent billions of dollars stockpiling the medication in preparation for various flu epidemics. The extremely limited amount of Tamiflu data and a growing number of adverse events for the side effects of tamiflu attracted the attention of a Japanese doctor who publicly expressed his concern online. In response, the Cochrane Collaboration, a group dedicated to full disclosure of information related to medications, requested that all clinical study reports (CSR's) be turned over by Roche for independent analysis. The manufacturer was slow to comply, yet over the course of nearly five years, the Cochrane Collaboration eventually received all available data to evaluate the reality beneath Roche's powerful marketing campaign.
What are the Dangerous Side Effects of Tamiflu; Including Psychotic Events for children and adults
Once all the reports were finally surrendered by Roche, a much more accurate analysis could be made regarding the benefits vs. risks of oseltamivir. It was determined that Tamiflu does reduce the duration of flu-like symptoms from an average of seven to 6.3 days in adults, yet the associated risks were found to be much more common and severe than Roche initially reported. In children, symptoms were alleviated an average of 29 hours sooner in those not impacted by asthma, yet side effects were intensified in this group. The Cochrane Collaboration expressed concern over the following adverse reactions after statistically evaluating the CSRs:
- Nausea. Children and Adultes who received Tamiflu exhibited nearly twice as many incidents of nausea compared to those who received a placebo pill. When children were given the drug for prophylaxis purposes, Tamiflu increased the likelihood of nausea nearly four fold.
- Vomiting. Adults taking Tamiflu were three times as likely to vomit; children taking Tamiflu suffered five times as many incidents compared to placebo.
- Headaches. Both children and adults were more likely to develop headaches while taking Tamiflu; because the effect was found to be dose dependent, those taking higher amounts and/or participating in longer prophylaxis trials were impacted more frequently.
- Neuropsychiatric events. Tamiflu doubles a person's odds of experiencing one or more dangerous psychotic episodes which may include suicidal attempts. Children are affected more often than adults.
- Renal impairment. Tamiflu impairs kidney function, as measured by creatinine clearance.
- Electrocardiographic anomalies. During treatment periods, people were more likely to develop an abnormal cardiac rhythm, as measure by QTc prolongation.
Side Effects of Tamiflu | An Unclear Mechanism of Action
According to the Tamiflu package insert:
"The relationship between the antiviral activity in cell culture and the inhibition of influenza virus replication in humans has not been established. "
While Roche claims that oseltamivir interferes with the replication of type A and/or B influenza virus in cell culture, no tests have shown that the same or similar mechanism occurs in the human body. There is, in fact, evidence suggesting that oseltamivir actually suppresses the body's immune response, as evidenced by reduced antibody production. Because Tamiflu is also a central nervous system depressant that slows brain function, it is possible that the drug's apparent flu-symptom shortening abilities exist primarily as a result of its sedative properties.
No Evidence in Support of Transmission Interruption
Much of what initially inspired the stockpiling of Tamiflu for children and adults was Roche's claim that oseltamivir has the ability to interrupt transmission of the A and/or B type flu virus. Once the entire data set was analyzed by the Cochrane Collaboration, however, no evidence was found to support this claim. Considering the governmental rationale to distribute oseltamivir to large portions of the population in the event of a flu epidemic, Cochrane's statistical analysis is of critical importance. Tamiflu does not reduce the spread of flu yet large scale distribution would needlessly put millions of people at risk of dangerous side effects.
Poorly Designed Clinical Tamiflu Trials With High Bias
Independent scientists conclude that the majority of Tamiflu's clinical trials contained a considerable amount of bias and poor design. Roche, the organization which stood to make a fortune from the product, sponsored 40 clinical trials to obtain FDA approval yet was only required to disclose information from a small percentage of those trials to achieve this goal. In those studies, the definitions used to describe various complications of the flu were vague and many required participants to "self report" side effects. Another concern of note involved the placebo, which contained dehydrocholic acid and dibasic calcium phosphate dihydrate, compounds known to irritate the intestinal tract and cause diarrhea. Cochrane concluded that such compounds were likely responsible for the apparent diarrhea suppressing qualities of Tamiflu and Tamiflu side effects, which do not contain these substances. Numerous other design and reporting issues were noted, including poorly documented adverse events, ghost authorship and conclusions which were based on weak or non-existent evidence.
If You are a Child or an Adult with Side Effects from Tamiflu |
Contact us to see if your Situation is Ripe for a Class Action Lawsuit
Thousands of people have experienced one or more of the adverse events associated with Tamiflu's side effects. Roche's withholding of information along with its advertising campaign which was labeled "false and misleading" by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration in November 2000 put the company in a position of accountability for harm done to thousands if not millions of unknowing people who took Tamiflu before all the facts were revealed. If you or someone you love has experienced Tamiflu side effects, a professional attorney may be able to help you obtain compensation.
Accolades for Weltchek Mallahan & Weltchek
OVER $600 MILLION IN VERDICTS & SETTLEMENTS FOR OUR CLIENTS